The philosophy behind Monotheism
Ruby Lemley rl123@uakron.edu
We often think of our modern religions stemming from revolutionary figures, dialectical stories passed down through time, or even abstract cosmic events, but we rarely give any consideration to the philosophical foundations of monotheistic religions or the thinkers that developed them. One of these philosophers who doesn’t get nearly as much recognition as he deserves is Anaxagoras of Clazomenae. Anaxagoras was one of the earliest figures to bring philosophy to the Greek city of Athens, and was contemporaries with other notable figures such as Socrates, Empedocles, and Parmenides. Anaxagoras was a scholar of many different subjects, such as meteorology, physics, and metaphysics, but his most prominent and revolutionary ideas were his thoughts on cosmology and the concept of nous. Anaxagoras lived in a time where the main objective of many philosophers was to discover the creation of the universe and its origin, so naturally, he came up with his own theories.
Anaxagoras posits that the universe, or cosmos, is an infinite expansion consisting of mixtures of the Parmenidean elements (earth, water, air, fire, and aether). The observable universe, or everything that we experience, was created by a force called nous. Nous is generally described as a pure and unmixed intellect; it is a sentient force that is distinct from the elements. This distinction makes nous the dominant element, and this combined with its sentience allows it the power to control the movements, permutations, and combinations of all of the elements. Nous orchestrated the creation of the observable universe by creating a swirling vortex within the cosmos, which led the mixed elements of the universe to create observable objects, as everything that we experience is created by different mixtures of the elements.
Anaxagoras’s account of the creation of the universe isn’t exactly like the modern conception of creating something out of nothing, but nonetheless resembles the powers that the Christian God and Islamic Allah had over creation. Anaxagoras claims, unlike Christianity, Islam, and Judaism, that the cosmos has always existed and is infinite, and the observable universe was created from its contents. Though God and Allah are said to be infinite themselves and existed before the creation of the universe, they still retain the same power over creation that nous displays in Anaxagoras’s cosmology.
More obviously, nous shares some of the fundamental characteristics of monotheistic gods, which are omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. That is, nous shares the descriptions with God and Allah as beings that have unlimited power over everything, know everything, and defy the laws of physics by being everywhere all at once.
Nous gets its power and ability to control the elements through its separation from them. The property of nous being unmixed and the dominant element in all things causes the elements to act in accordance with it. This makes nous omnipotent, as it retains the power to control the swirling vortex of the cosmos, movements of the elements, and therefore also controls all of the objects made by combination of the elements. Nous is also described as omnipresent, co-existing everywhere with the infinite universe. Additionally, nous is uniquely described as being present within some objects, specifically in living things. Nous enters into certain things such as humans, plants, and creatures in order to produce life, motion, and consciousness. This description is almost an exact parallel to Christianity’s description of God existing within living things. In the Christian Bible, God was said to have created living things by blowing the “breath of life” into them, and specifically continues to exist within humans through the holy spirit. This comparison is a distinct show of parallels that exist between the idea of nous and modern religions, and demonstrates how Anaxagoras’s ideas were directly included in the philosophical foundations of some religions.
Arguments that are typically used to support religion and the existence of a god can also be used to support Anaxagoras’s ideas and the existence of nous. Specifically, the fine tuning argument, when used to argue for religion, posits that the specific conditions that are necessary for existence and life are so narrow and improbable that they must have been created by some kind of higher power or god. This argument supports many religions, as the omniscient and omnipotent gods would have the knowledge of the conditions needed for life and existence, and would have the power to create things that are compatible with those specificities. Though Anaxagoras didn’t use this argument himself to support his ideas, it can still be used to bolster his points about nous. As an all-knowing intelligence, nous would likewise be aware of the requirements for our existence and life, and as the dominant element, would be able to control the mixing of the elements in order to create life accordingly.
Anaxagoras used his idea of nous to argue against and reject hellenic polytheism, which was the dominant religion of Greece during his lifetime. This rejection of polytheism in favor of more scientific explanation and certain qualities of nous can be used to argue for a form of atheism. Unlike the gods of modern monotheisms, nous doesn’t actively interact with humanity or judge morality. Instead, it acts as a mechanical perpetrator of creation and life, and this could lead to a claim that nous doesn’t have the full properties as a monotheistic god has.
However, the basis of these claims fundamentally misunderstand Anaxagoras’s intentions in arguing for the existence of nous. Anaxagoras never claimed to be an atheist or argued against religion in its entirety, but he specifically rejected hellenic polytheism and the superstition and anthropomorphism that accompanied it. An example of this can be seen in Anaxagoras’s cosmological views, distinctly in his claim that the sun was a flaming ball of metal rather than the god Helios. His pattern of removing divine attributes from tangible objects is identical to the path taken by early Christian and Jewish thinkers who claimed that nature was not itself divine, but was a creation of the divine. We also need to bring to question the assumption that a god must possess the ability to act as a moral agent. Though this idea of gods judging the rights and wrongs of humanity is a popular one, it is a concept that is primarily attributed to anthropomorphic gods, which is a notion that Anaxagoras directly argued against. Not judging human sins doesn’t mean that nous doesn’t possess a form of divine good, rather, nous portrays its form of goodness through creating cosmic order.
Anaxagoras’s idea of nous portrays essentially the same view of a higher power or god as monotheistic religions do, as nous shares the same core qualities of the monotheistic gods and can be supported using the same arguments. Not only does nous share the characteristics of being omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent with modern ideas of god, but it also shares a somewhat similar account of how the observable universe was created. Furthermore, some of Anaxagoras’s ideas were incorporated directly into the development of modern monotheisms. Early Chistian and Jewish theologians such as Philo of Alexandria, Justin Martyr, and Augustine defended themselves against accusations of impiety by the Roman Empire by utilizing the arguments of Anaxagoras, utilizing his ideas to make intellectual frameworks to legitimize their religions. They used his philosophical ideas both as a foundation and a shield for their faiths. Anaxagoras’s idea of nous served as a foundational bridge for early Christian, Islamic, and Jewish theologians to break away from hellenic polytheism and other similar religions to develop their own ideas of monotheistic religions instead.


Comments