Down a Rabbit hole (A Tiny Door, Really): Coraline Conspiracy Theories

AnnaMarie Harper, ah484@uakron.edu
You may be familiar with the eerie film Coraline, which follows a curious girl dissatisfied with her “boring” and “regular” life who discovers a mysterious door leading to her seemingly perfect world. At first, this new world appears to offer everything she has ever wanted, but beneath it lies something much more dark and twisted. While the film has captivated audiences with its unsettling atmosphere and disturbing imagery, many viewers believe there is more to the story and with careful analysis of hidden details and subtle clues, fans have developed numerous conspiracy theories that attempt to uncover a deeper meaning within the film.
In the film , Coraline is able to travel to the other world by going through a tiny door. But what if that wasn’t the original entrance? One fan theorizes that the well near the Pink Palace might be the first or original portal connecting both worlds together. When the well is first discovered by Coraline, it’s surrounded by mushrooms which is known as a “fairy ring.” In folklore, these rings are sometimes used as an entrance to the supernatural world. This suggests that Coraline may have stepped inside one after coming in contact with it and also possibly foreshadow her journey into the Beldam’s world. In relation to this theory, some also say that the Beldam’s lair, which is dark with a somewhat hexagonal shape, is similar to the bottom of a well, theorizing that the two locations could be connected as well.
My personal favorite theory suggests that Wybie’s grandma “sacrificed” Coraline, so that Wybie wouldn’t be the Beldam’s next victim. Early in the film, Wybie encounters a family that has just moved into the Pink Palace. He seems a little shocked and maybe even confused as he explains that his grandma, Mrs. Lovat doesn’t usually rent to families with children. This ends up making more sense later in the film as to why; we later learn that the twin sister of Wybie’s grandmother disappeared when they were younger. We also learn that the twin sisters’ disappearance comes from the Beldam, who lures them into the other world, tricking them with a “perfect life.” Considering that Mrs. Lovat had lost her twin sister, it only makes sense that she would want to protect her grandson from the same thing. In the film, Mrs. Lovat appears to have not known about the Beldamn but her actions sparks two questions: why would Mrs. Lovat makes an exception to this particular family, and why would she allow it if she knew it wasn’t safe? People believe that since she knew to keep Wybie away, but allowed Coraline and her family to stay, she must’ve deliberately put Coraline at risk by the Beldam so that she could keep Wybie safe.
This last theory definitely lives up to the idea of “too good to be true.” One of the more common theories questions whether or not Coraline actually escaped the Beldam. This theory suggests that when Coraline was captured in the Other Mother’s world, but had finally “escaped,” it turned out to be an indistinguishable blur between reality and illusion. Throughout the film, the Beldam repeatedly uses illusions to replicate things of Coraline's reality and desired reality; the Beldam used illusions to create her father, Wybie, things that she wanted in her real world, and even herself, Coraline's mother. In one scene, where Coraline believes she's home to her mother, hugging her, the Other Mother starts transforming into the Beldam. Because the Beldam is capable of doing all these things—making Coraline’s life seem better, there's a possibility that she never really escaped at all, and the Beldam is using illusions to imitate a seemingly “happy ending” for Coraline, keeping her in the Other World.
While none of these theories are confirmed to be true, the details leading up to them leave much room for speculation and offer many interesting perspectives.


Comments