Moana 2... A Disappointment?

Gabby Burgan - stu220261@apslearns.org
Who is your favorite Disney princess? Personally, I’m partial to Moana. So like everyone else who enjoyed the first movie, I went to see Moana 2 in theatres when it came out in 2024. Despite the movie being a box office success, I left the movie underwhelmed and disappointed. The sequel wasn’t anywhere close to being as good as the original Moana was. For me, there were three reasons why that was: Story, characters, and soundtrack.
The story itself had a lot of potential. The main plot was that Motunui used to be connected to other islands and their people, and Moana wanted to reunite everyone against the wishes of the god Nalo, who was the one to separate and isolate the islands in the first place. However, the execution left much to be desired. One reason for this is because the plot and events of the movie were originally intended to be in the form of a Moana series released on Disney+. But after seeing early footage of the show, former Disney CEO Bob Iger decided that it should be made into a feature length film in order to maximize the amount of money it generated. Obviously, the writing and pacing for a tv series and for a movie is very different. So, because they were translating the series writing to a movie, a lot of the small conflicts in the movie that would have been the main conflict of an episode began to feel like they were misplaced and distracting from the overall movie. During the entirety of the film, there simply seemed to be too much going on that there was little room left for the main story the movie was trying to tell.
Additionally, the god Nalo was never actually seen on screen until a short scene after the end credits. Despite the fact that he was the main antagonist, all the conflicts he imposed were things like storms and other natural disasters. Having Nalo as an onscreen antagonist would’ve greatly increased the amount they could’ve done with the story. Personally, I think we should’ve gotten a villain song and an actual interaction between him, Moana, and Maui, because he apparently had prior beef with Nalo, instead of their enemy only being Nalo’s imposed storms.
Regarding the characters, Moana 2 introduced a variety of side characters that, overall, added nothing to the story and were very one dimensional. Let’s start with the side characters who were accompanying Moana on her journey. They were so undeveloped, in fact, that the entirety of their characters can be summed up in labels. Fanboy, quirky engineer, and grumpy old farmer. That is all the new characters were. They didn’t actually add any value to the story, and it could have mostly been told the same way without them. And, because they were so underdeveloped, the audience couldn’t form a connection to them and they were highly forgettable.
Another character that was later introduced was Matangi, a trapped servant of Nalo who went against his orders to help Moana. She sings a song, helps them out, and then she’s never seen or mentioned by any of the characters again. The only time the audience sees her again is in the end credit scene with Nalo. While her character was necessary to the story, the way she was handled seemed to use her as a throwaway character, when she should’ve had more of a lasting impact on the story.
The original Moana soundtrack was written by Lin Manuel Miranda, best known for creating the musical Hamilton. He delivered the iconic songs “How Far I’ll Go” and “You’re Welcome”. Because of the soundtrack success, you’d assume they would rehire him to write the Moana 2 soundtrack, right? Wrong. Because the movie was originally going to be a tv series, they already had songs created from the songwriters Abigail Marlow and Emily Bear, who most notably created the concept album “Bridgerton: The Musical.” Needless to say, the final soundtrack for Moana 2 was… disappointing. While one or two songs were alright, Moana’s main song “Beyond” and Maui’s song “Can I get a Chee Hoo?” were nowhere near the level of “How Far I’ll Go” and “You’re Welcome”. It seemed like they tried to mimic Miranda’s writing style, but it didn’t really work out. While I do think the pair are talented writers based on their Bridgerton songs, I believe they should’ve been hired as songwriters for an original movie. Because they were writing for a sequel, the songs were inherently going to be judged in comparison to the music of the first movie, where the bar was already raised pretty high.
As a fan of the first movie, Moana 2 was pretty disappointing. However, because it was a box office success, a third one is confirmed to be in development. Despite my disappointment, there is a lot of potential for the story of the third one and I’m hoping they execute it better!


Comments